am i missing something?
I watched it twice just to make sure that I wasn't missing something that everyone else seems to see in this, but I still don't get it. The animation in the beginning is terrible, the fight scene is good - not great - sounds were terrible, and it wasn't funny (was it even supposed to be?). I really just didn't like this. I'm afraid this is a case of front page = automatic ratings of 10.
Some people are arguing that the whole point of it was for the animation to look like crap and the sound to be shit, but then doesn't that just make this a crappy submission altogether? I know there are submissions that satirize terrible animation, like badly drawn dog, but theres a huge difference between something like badly drawn dog and this. While BDG does have poorly animated characters, the sounds are dead on, the cartoon is well structured, and the poor animation highlights the comedy. In contrast, I just think 85% of this submission is crap. Like I said before, if the point of the cartoon is to have crappy animation, crappy sound, crappy structure, and one good fight scene, then what is it beside a crappy submission with one good fight scene?
If this submission was the fight alone, I would be happy to vote 6 or 7. But as a whole, I give you a 4. Although you put effort into the fight scene, the rest was bullshit.
That said, I think if you put more time into your work you could make something really incredible. You certainly have the ability.